Schools Across California Access High-speed Broadband Service for the First Time
Teachers in the El Tejon Unified School District, which serves the mountain communities in southwestern Kern County, faced daily challenges due to inadequate Internet connectivity. Corey Hansen was unable to enter grades or attendance online when another teacher in her school was also trying to do so. Any media to be used in instruction had to be downloaded off-site and brought to school on a flash drive. Students were unable to access Google accounts at school to complete assigned work. During state testing, the school was limited to having 20 students at a time in the computer lab. As a result, the testing window was longer than a month, which meant students were not performing at their best. It also meant that the district office, school office, and classroom teachers could not be online at the same time, which crippled the entire district.
Challenges like these have inspired the creation of the Broadband Infrastructure Improvement Grant program, an initiative funded by the California State Legislature in to connect the hardest-to-serve schools in California to CalREN, Corporation for Education Networking in California’s (CENIC) high-capacity broadband network. Through a partnership between the K-12 High-Speed Network (K12HSN), the California Department of Education, and CENIC, work is now underway to upgrade Internet connectivity to 326 of the hardest-to-serve schools in the state. Most of these schools will receive a symmetrical broadband connection of 1 Gbps. In addition, more than 80% of these upgrades will employ fiber-optic based solutions, ensuring that these schools will have the fiber infrastructure necessary to increase capacity when needed. Approximately 92,000 students will benefit from connectivity upgrades.
When these obstacles are overcome, and connectivity is complete, the impact on the lives of teachers and students can be significant. After the connectivity upgrade was complete at the El Tejon Unified School District, Corey Hansen reflected on the impact on teaching and learning in her school. “I can now have an entire class on their Chromebook computers, accessing reading and language arts materials. Comprehension questions, note taking, critical thinking, questioning, and communication with parents have all improved. Students can use their computers on a daily basis for writing, research, note-taking, and other essential aspects of their academic work. I am able to run an after-school tutoring program utilizing an online standards-based tutorial that can individualize and accelerate student learning.”
Students have noticed the upgraded connection speeds as well. They are excited and willing to work on their Chromebooks and enthusiastic about participating in daily lessons. Because the connectivity upgrade has allowed for immediate teacher feedback to both students and parents, there is a greater knowledge of what is required and expected. Parents see the benefits of deeper connection to the school because they can readily access the curriculum and student progress.
Multiple steps need to be coordinated among multiple parties to successfully install these circuits. In addition to K12HSN, CENIC, and the service provider, installation needs to be coordinated with the County Office of Education and with school technology and facilities staff. Timelines need to be aligned, and all parties need to understand the steps and timelines. Internet circuit installation, when all fiber infrastructure is in place, can take 90 days. If fiber infrastructure needs to be created, it can take 120 to 210 days, depending on the challenges encountered.
Work begins when a school demonstrates to K12HSN that it qualifies for inclusion in the Broadband Infrastructure Fund. CENIC then seeks bids for telecommunications services and arranges for federal E-rate discounts and California Teleconnect Fund discounts on behalf of schools. Through a Request for Proposals process, CENIC obtains quotes for service from Internet service providers, evaluates those quotes which include connectivity speeds, hardware needs—if any—and costs. Once these quotes for service are approved by a K-12 stakeholder group and the school district, CENIC prepares the specifications for the circuit and places an order with the service provider.
The service provider then conducts a site survey and completes any preparatory work necessary to ensure they can deliver service to the site. Especially at the hardest-to connect schools, the service provider sometimes needs to undertake special construction to deliver the circuit, such as digging a trench to run fiber to a school site. One of the biggest benefits of this broadband improvement program is that grant funds cover the one-time cost of special construction, which can be significant for many schools in the program.
In addition, the school must ensure that the room where the circuit will be delivered meets minimum requirements and that all necessary local area network equipment is in place. Often schools have a very limited capacity to prepare their site and K12HSN steps in to provide assistance to the site. School personnel can point out where the circuit should be delivered and help uncover environmental issues, but often do not have the technical expertise to prepare the site, so an outside resource needs to be brought in to assist.
Despite significant progress statewide, significant challenges remain in some communities. Robert Jackson, Director of Technology for the Trinity County Office of Education, still faces tremendous challenges in bringing high-speed broadband to schools in his county. The county has a small population base and schools, such as Burnt Ranch Elementary, can have as few as 100 students. The topography of the county is also a huge challenge. Located in the northwestern-most corner of California, the terrain is rugged and mountainous. With its geographic challenges and small population base, Trinity County has very little fiber infrastructure and few Internet service providers to support high-speed broadband connectivity.
When fiber is not an option, microwave connectivity is a less-desirable alternative. But even this is a challenge in Trinity County. At Cox Bar Elementary, the topography is such that they are in a “bowl” and have no line of sight to any mountain. Antennas can be mounted in trees as a last resort but, on US Forest Service and Native lands, it is nearly impossible to get permission to put up an antenna. And even when it is possible, it is expensive, and rockslides and weather present challenges in maintaining any terrestrial construction.
Trinity County is not the only region of the state where obstacles to improved Internet connectivity exist. From telephone poles that cannot hold any more fiber to granite boulders in the fiber path, CENIC staff are presented with complex problems to solve every day. For example, in Sonoma County, the commercial service provider has been working since April 2015 to obtain right-of-way access to run fiber to a rural school but has been unable to obtain permission from private landowners to place fiber on existing power poles on their land. And in Kern County, one of the schools to be served is on a military base, and coordination with military sanctioned contractors has been complex.
In communities across California, the digital divide is being closed one school at a time. But in some communities, the challenges to high-speed broadband connectivity are so significant they can not be addressed by the K-12 community working alone. It will take the collaboration of many institutions and individuals in a community to solve this problem. In addition, project leaders know that is not enough simply to upgrade the connectivity to schools. Young people learn within their communities—at home, in libraries, and in other public spaces. Work on the Broadband Infrastructure initiative has led all parties to ask: How do we bring high-speed broadband to whole geographies so that students, teachers, families, and all community members can learn anytime, anywhere? This questions will guide work in the future until all communities in California have equal access to high-speed broadband and to the opportunities it creates.